Cassian - Shop recommendations?

[Coronet ()]

Dear all,

my boyfriend is looking into joining the RL with a Cassian costume. As we´re on a rather tight budget atm something like Magnoli is not an option for us and sadly there´s no time to sew it myself. So we´ve looked into the different "budget" versions which we´ve seen other RL members use (of course with at least some modifications like weathering, adding a few seams...).

These are the shops we´ve come up with:

1. ProCosplay

2. Ebay Seller Cosplayshow

From the pictures it looks to me as if they might be the same and we´ve seen other chinese sellers use the same pictures, so we´re not really sure if there is an "original source" for this costume and if we can expect the quality from the picture (with other costumes I´ve made the experience that the quality can often greatly differ from the advertised pictures and that the sellers just steal each others pictures, but of course the sellers could all be supplied by the same wholeseller...).
Does anyone here use one of the above and could maybe show a few pictures of their costume (and maybe even show which changes you did to make it approvable)?
Or from a judges perspective which one would you recommend? We´ve also seen a costume from Oasis, but I think this would be a bit to much work compared to the others? With the ruffled waistband it might not be the best base to start from.

We´re open to any recommendations and I hope some of you might be able to help us out :)

Thank you and mtfbwy
_________________
"They were in the wrong place at the wrong time. Naturally they became heroes."
Princess Leia Organa

[tenebris (empathy)]

I'll discuss this with the DCO and get back to you.
_________________
RLGSC, DXO
BMO Elstree Base UK
CO Home One Command, Elstree Base UK ( Rebel Officers Detachment)

[jeniwan (Jenna Hunt)]

There is a Cassian-focused group on Facebook and I think they’ll have lots of good advice there. We have definitely approved members with Chinese-purchased costumes, and with a few mods these costumes can look quite nice. I’m just not sure where exactly people buy them.

Here’s the group: https://m.facebook.com/groups/139172823300974?ref=share
(Be sure to answer the approval questions when you request to join.)
_________________
*
Legion Costume Judge -- Rey / Jyn Erso / Cassian Andor
*
Great Lakes Base -- Rey (Resistance, Jakku, TLJ and Training) Jyn Erso
*
Oh and that one time I made a wookiee: www.instagram.com/latch_wooking

[RebelLady (Kristina Gundersen)]

I agree with Jenna's comments about some of the less expensive versions being able to be modded for approval with some work.

Here's what I see that would need to be updated at first glance:

1. That vinyl rank badge needs to go.

2. The commpad needs to be replaced with a more accurate one and needs to be inside a windowed pocket

3. Any snaps would need to be colored to blend with the jacket a bit more. If they can be removed without fabric integrity issues, they should be replaced with an invisible closure like velcro. I am really confused as to why they put ones on the shirt cuffs. That's just silly.

4. I'm not entirely sure that shirt is modable. It depends entirely on whether or not that extended belly seam is structural or decorative. If it is decorative the extra bits on either side of the bib can be removed and topstitching used to create the missing sides. If it is structural, the seam type would need to be played with so that it doesn't show quite so much. We've had several people apply with this shirt, and it pulls really oddly.



5. The whole thing would need weathering.

6. The belt/holster rig, boots and vest are questionable. The vest is not needed for approval. The holster/belt and boots you will be better off replacing. (They are the wrong color among other things.)

7. It is missing the PLCE belt.

8. The energy pellet greebs are missing.

There may be other bits as well, but those are the ones that jump out right now.


_________________
Legion Costuming Judge: Officers, Rebel Supporters
Galactic Strategic Command, DCO
Yavin Command Post, Duty Officer
Sunrider Base Charity Officer 2016-18
-------------------------------------------------------
Mon Mothma, OT Pilot, Willrow Hood, Resistance Officer, General Leia Organa (Raddus Bridge), ANH General, Mirax Terrik, Lyra Erso